Rug Quality – The Definitive Guide

High quality rug in living room

Contents:

Complete the form on the right to download a PDF version of this article to keep and read at your leisure

 


Introduction

The rug market can be a confusing place to navigate. Specialist language on qualities and materials can be hard to decipher, and without the correct knowledge, telling apart a high and low quality rug by eye is almost impossible. Prices of rugs can vary hugely, anfew people really understand what they are paying for. However, at Bazaar Velvet we are here to de-code this complex topic for our clients, so they can find a rug that is the perfect fit.


Constructions:

When it comes to rug construction, one of the biggest misconceptions is that all rugs labelled ‘Handmade’ are equal. It’s a loose term that’s often used to distract from an inferior product and doesn’t necessarily mean no machines have been used in production. The way a rug has been made will have a great effect on its appearance and how it wears with use, so it’s important to understand the difference between each. Here’s our breakdown of the different types of rug construction and how to identify them.

 

Hand Knotted

Hand knotted rugs epitomise premium quality, and are made using traditional methods dating back hundreds of years. Skilled artisans work on a wooden loom set up using cotton threads know as warps. They knot wool or silk yarns around each thread by hand, following each row with a cotton weft thread to keep the knots in place. The rug then undergoes several stages of hand-finishing, including trimming, washing, binding and stretching. A 300x240cm rug can take over 6 months to complete and will contain over a million hand tied knots.

hand knotted rug quality

This technique produces the most robust rug possible. A quality hand knotted rug is almost indestructible, and even with heavy use can last a lifetime. Many high-end interior designers demand only hand knotted rugs. Peter Mikic is one such example; ‘… all my rugs are made in Nepal, traditionally hand-knotted using Tibetan wool, Chinese silk hemp and linen.’

Hand Knotted rugs can be easily cleaned, and areas can even be rewoven if required. Go to one of the leading auction houses and you can find examples of hand knotted rugs that are over two hundred years old.

There are many ways in which a hand knotted rug can be identified. Firstly, the design can be seen from the reverse side of the rug, as can the knots, which will all be slightly different in size and shape. Also, there will be no signs of glue and edges will be slightly irregular and bound by hand.

Find out more about the creation of a hand knotted rug at http://bazaarvelvet.com/hand-knotted-rugs/ 

 

Hand Tufted

hand tufted rug quality

This is the most obvious example of where the use of the title ‘Handmade’ is slightly dubious. These rugs are in fact made by a hand-held machine called a tufting gun. 

It effectively injects fibres into a fabric backing, which will then be sealed by a type of glue or latex. The back of the rug will then be covered by a heavy-duty fabric such as jute or canvas, so this is an easy way to tell a Hand Tufted Rug apart from its counterparts.

Essentially, the properties of this type of rug fall somewhere between a machine made and hand knotted rug. The process is much faster than hand knotting (usually around 2-3 months) but the finished product doesn’t have the same quality, character or longevity.

Our Core Collection rugs come in a hand knotted quality as standard but can be created in a hand tufted quality on request.

 VIEW OUR CORE COLLECTION

 

Hand Loomed

hand loomed rug qualityThis type of rug is one consumers should be very wary of, as its outward appearance is very similar to a hand knotted rug, but it has many issues regarding wear. It is created on a manually powered loom, with levers pulling and pushing the fibres together. Unlike a hand tufted rug, these are not secured at the back but only held in place by the pressure of the other fibres. They are therefore very unstable, prone to stretching and wrinkling, and easily damaged by hoovers or even just everyday use.

One of the easiest ways to identify a Hand Loomed rug is by checking for ‘grinning’. Folding the rug inwards will reveal loose white threading on the back of the rug. Also, from the front of the rug, V-shaped fibres can easily be pulled out by hand.

Learn more about the dangers of a hand loomed rug at https://cleanfax.com/cleanfax-insider/rug-to-run-from-india-hand-loomed/

 

Machine Made

machine made rug qualityFor this type of rug, a computerised machine will work on a ‘power loom’ to inject material into a backing which is very insecure. The process takes only a matter of hours and will produce a completely uniform design. This is the fastest and most economical rug making method- most rugs you find in high street stores will be made this way.

This type of rug can be identified by a grid of white threads on the back. Also, its overall appearance will be mechanical, with perfectly uniform edges, design and texture- lacking the character of other constructions. The longevity of a machine-made rug is extremely variable, depending mainly on its density and materials, but generally isn’t expected to last more than 10 years. 

 Find out more about the difference between a hand made a machine made rug at http://www.rugzone.co.uk/blog/blog1.php/methods-of-rug-production

 

Rug Qualities Summarised 


rug qualities comparison chart

 

 


Additional features found in a hand knotted rug:

It’s not only the hand knotting itself that gives a rug it’s character. There are many other processes involved in it’s creation which may or may not be completed by hand. You may hear the phrases below used to describe a hand knotted rug. Every one of these techniques will have an impact on the finish of the rug:

hand spinning

Hand-carded

The purpose of carding is to separate and clean wool fibres. Untreated wool is placed between two paddles with metal bristles (similar to a hairbrush) and pulled through them.

Hand-dyed

Measures of dye are calculated by eye and poured into a vat of water boiling over a primitive fire. The yarns are added and turned in the mixture on a wheel over several days

Hand-spun

Spinning wool yarn on a traditional spinning wheel rather than by machine creates yarn of slightly varying thicknesses. When knotted, this irregularity will be passed onto the rug itself giving a texture that is full of character.  

Hand-carved

This is a process that is necessary when creating a rug with varying pile heights- often a high pile silk design on a low pile wool background. To begin with, the rug (which comes off the loom shaggy) is trimmed to just one pile height. Then the wool is cut to a lower level leaving the silk raised. This process is completed by skilled artisans who use small shears to effectively ‘carve’ out the silk details of the design.

Find out more about what makes a hand knotted rugs so special at http://blog.bazaarvelvet.com/luxury-in-the-detail or view our beautiful Bohemia range for stunning examples of intricately hand carved rugs.

 VIEW OUR BOHEMIA COLLECTION

 

Different Hand Knotted Qualities:

The ‘quality’ of a hand knotted rug often refers to its pile density or ‘knot count’. This is the number of knots found in a set area of the rug. It is measured differently according to the rugs country of origin, but essentially the same rules apply.

hand carvingFor Nepalese rugs, knots are counted per liner foot.
For example, in our popular ‘100 knot’ quality you will find 100 hand tied knots in a foot long row.
Knot counts range from 60 knot to 200 knot.

For Indian rugs, knots are counted per square inch.
For example, in our popular ‘11/11 quality’ you will find 121 hand tied knots inside a 11inch by 11inch square.
Qualities range from 5/5 to 16/16.

The knot count of a rug doesn’t so much affect its durability, but its scope for design. The higher the knot count the more detail can be achieved. A low knot count rug will be limited to a simple geometric design, as attempting tight curves or small details will result in jagged edges and pixilation. Although a rug with a higher knot count will appear finer, with a crisper definition and shorter pile, it will be more expensive due to the increased labour needed to tie more knots. Also, increase the knot count too much and a design can look too perfect and mechanical, losing its handmade charm.

 

nepalese and indian knot count qualities explained white background

 

 


Materials:

The range of different fibres that can be used to create rugs is extremely vast. All have there benefits and downfalls, but some have quite serious quality implications. Unfortunately, not all rug retailers are completely transparent about the material content of their rugs, so it’s important to ask before you buy. Also, be careful of silk imitations- real silk is an expensive material so expect this to be reflected in the rugs price. The rug advice of Interior designer and regular AD magazine contributor Laura Hunt is to “Make sure it’s made from natural materials.”

 

Wool

hand knotted abstract rug close up

Wool is generally regarded as the benchmark material for rug making. It is extremely durable, soft strong and warm. One of the greatest advantages of this fibre is its elasticity. This means the pile springs back into shape after being walked upon or weighed down by furniture. However, different types of wool vary in quality. New Zealand wool is generally well regarded, with producers attracted to its natural whiteness which makes it easier to dye. However, at Bazaar Velvet we prefer more more luxurious wools, such as Bikaner or Himalayan. This is because they are high in a natural oil called lanolin which makes the wool extremely soft and acts as a natural stain resistor.

Find out more at http://blog.bazaarvelvet.com/shear-delights

 

Genuine Silk

Genuine silk is derived from the cocoon of a silk worm. Generally, genuine silk is sourced from China which has a long history in manufacturing the fibre. Although natural silk is more delicate than wool (particularly when exposed to liquid) it is in fact much more stain resistant than imitation silk (see below). Nothing surpasses the luxury of a 100% silk rug, but for a high traffic area, a mainly wool rug with silk highlights is a more practical option, and the contrast between the matt and sheen of the two materials can be quite stunning.

We use this combination in many of our collections, including our popular core range. 

VIEW OUR CORE COLLECTION

 

Synthetics (wool alternatives)

Acrylic, polyester and polypropylene are all common materials for inexpensive machine-made rugs. These synthetics are easy to care for and the fibre is generally quite strong, but their big downfall is their pile is very susceptible to crushing. Even after moderate foot traffic, they will quickly appear worn. Although some synthetics can give a similar appearance to wool, their dryness and artificial feel is apparent to the touch.

Artificial ‘Art’ Silk

Art silk is a common name given to the material Viscose (also known as Rayon). Viscose comes neither under the heading of synthetic or natural, but is instead categorized as a ‘regenerated’ fibre. This is because although it is created from the cellulose of machine made viscose rug-1plants, it is processed using chemicals. Tencel or lyocell for example, is a type of viscose that originates from wood pulp which is given a specific treatment that makes it stronger than many other forms of viscose. Bamboo Silk and Banana Silk are also types of viscose, created from the dried cellulose of the bamboo and banana plants. As far as durability is concerned, Art Silk should be approached with caution. A rug made completely from this material is not suitable for high traffic areas, as it wears badly. Also, liquid stains can be very problematic. Even plain water can mark badly and cause damage to the structure of the rug itself.

 Find out more at https://www.contrado.co.uk/blog/what-is-viscose/

 

When deciding on a material, it is important to remember the rugs setting. Kate Mooney of Houseolgy says ‘Ask yourself some questions. What is the room used for? Who uses it and how often? Your answers will have an impact on your choice.’ https://www.houzz.co.uk/ideabooks/60650895/list/how-to-choose-the-right-rug-for-your-space


Conclusion:

I hope this article provides a useful explanation of what separates a high-quality and low-quality rug, and the signs to be aware of when making a purchase. There really are a wealth of options, so make sure you choose one you love that will serve your needs for many years to come.

bohemia antique white soft grey room (2)

Above: Bohemia Antique White Soft Grey

At Bazaar Velvet, all of our rugs are created to last a lifetime. We are committed to the traditional method of hand knotting and use only the best quality materials. Browse our collections now.

VIEW ALL COLLECTIONS

Sources:

  • Mark Gonsenhausers rug and carpet superstore
  • Modern Rugs
  • Rug Zone
  • Love Rugs
  • Cleanfax
  • Rug Mart
  • Rug Knots
  • Contrado
  • Rug Chick
  • Houzz

 

Further Reading:

View our other rug guides: